Key takeaways
- Compare five carbon steel pans from de Buyer, Matfer, Lodge, Merten and Storck and Misen, with sizes, seasoning needs and care tips for home cooks.
Carbon steel is the pan material many restaurant kitchens rely on for high-heat searing, and it has a simple makeup: iron with a small amount of carbon, rolled into a pan that is lighter than cast iron and quick to respond when you adjust the burner. There is no applied nonstick coating on a traditional carbon steel pan. Instead, the cooking surface is a layer of seasoning, meaning oil baked onto the bare steel, and that layer builds up as you cook.
That trade is worth understanding before you buy. A carbon steel pan asks for a little upkeep: hand washing, thorough drying, and an occasional touch of oil. In return, it tolerates very high heat, works on every common cooktop, and can last for decades because there is no coating to wear out. The five pans below cover the main styles, from unseasoned French skillets to pre-seasoned and nitrided options.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick Answer
For a classic French skillet, the de Buyer MINERAL B 12.25 inch and the Matfer Bourgeat 8.5 inch are bare carbon steel pans you season yourself. If you want to cook sooner, the Merten and Storck 12 inch and the Lodge 10 inch bundle arrive pre-seasoned, while the Misen 12 inch uses a nitrided surface with an aluminum core and no seasoning routine.
1. de Buyer MINERAL B Carbon Steel Fry Pan, 12.25 Inch
The MINERAL B is the reference point for French carbon steel: a Lyonnaise-style fry pan made in France from carbon steel that the maker describes as 99 percent pure iron. The sloped sides make it easy to slide and toss food, and the 12.25 inch rim leaves a 9 inch flat cooking surface, which is generous room for searing several portions at once without crowding.
This pan arrives with a beeswax finish that protects the steel in transit. That coating has to be removed and the pan seasoned before cooking, so plan on a break-in session before the first meal. The listing states the pan is made without PTFE or PFOA and has no chemical coating added; the cooking surface you end up with is the seasoning you build yourself.
Specs
- Diameter: 12.25 inches, with a 9 inch cooking surface
- Material: carbon steel, listed as 99 percent pure iron
- Finish as shipped: beeswax protective coating, removed before seasoning
- Applied coating: none, per the listing
- Origin: made in France
- Oven temperature limit: confirm on the listing
- Care: hand wash and dry thoroughly
2. Matfer Bourgeat Black Carbon Steel Frying Pan, 8.5 Inch
Matfer Bourgeat builds its black carbon steel pans from a single piece of uncoated high-carbon steel, and this 8.5 inch size is the compact end of the range. It suits one or two eggs, a single portion of fish, or small batches where a big skillet would be overkill. The listing gives an inner diameter of 8.75 inches, a 6.25 inch cooking surface, a 7 inch handle, and a weight of 2.1 pounds, so it is easy to lift and maneuver with one hand.
The handle is welded to the body rather than riveted, which leaves the inside smooth, with no rivet heads to clean around. The listing rates the pan for all hob types including induction, plus ovens, outdoor grills, and open fire. It also advises against cooking acidic ingredients such as lemon juice, vinegar, or tomato sauce in the pan, which is standard guidance for protecting seasoning. It arrives unseasoned, so the first seasoning sessions are part of the deal.
Specs
- Diameter: 8.5 inches (inner diameter listed as 8.75 inches)
- Cooking surface: 6.25 inches
- Material: single piece of uncoated high-carbon steel
- Handle: welded steel, 7 inches long, no interior rivets
- Weight: 2.1 pounds
- Compatibility: all hob types including induction, oven, grill, and open fire, per the listing
- Origin: made in France
- Seasoning: required before use
3. Merten and Storck Pre-Seasoned Carbon Steel 12 Inch Frying Pan
Merten and Storck takes the middle path: a full-size 12 inch carbon steel skillet that arrives pre-seasoned, so you can start cooking right away and let the surface keep improving with use. The brand has made cookware since 1873, and this model is listed for induction, stove, and grill use, as well as oven cooking and campfire cooking, which makes it a flexible single pan for indoor and outdoor cooking.
The listing rates the pan to a maximum temperature of 600 degrees Fahrenheit and lists a capacity of 4 cups and a weight of 1.5 kilograms. Pre-seasoning is a starting layer, not a finished one, so expect the surface to be at its best after some weeks of regular cooking with fats. Wash the pan before first use as the listing directs, and dry it fully to keep rust away.
Specs
- Diameter: 12 inches
- Material: carbon steel
- Seasoning: pre-seasoned at the factory
- Maximum temperature: 600 degrees Fahrenheit, per the listing
- Capacity: 4 cups
- Weight: 1.5 kilograms
- Model number: CC003337-001
- Compatibility: induction, stove, grill, oven, and campfire, per the listing
4. Lodge CRS10 Carbon Steel Skillet, 10 Inch, with Silicone Handle Holders
Lodge makes its carbon steel line in the USA, and this listing bundles the 10 inch CRS10 skillet with a pair of orange ASCRHH61 silicone hot handle holders. The skillet is made of 12 gauge carbon steel and comes pre-seasoned with vegetable oil, so it is ready to cook with straight out of the box. The 10 inch size is a practical everyday footprint for one or two servings, and the long steel handle suits stovetop tossing and oven transfers.
The included handle holders answer the main ergonomic complaint about bare steel handles, which heat up during long cooking sessions. Because this is a bundle listing, check it carefully if you only want the skillet on its own. Capacity and weight for the bundle are best confirmed on the listing.
Specs
- Diameter: 10 inches
- Material: 12 gauge carbon steel
- Seasoning: pre-seasoned with vegetable oil
- Included components: CRS10 skillet and ASCRHH61 silicone hot handle holders in orange
- Origin: made in the USA
- Model: CRS10
- Capacity and bundle weight: confirm on the listing
- Care: hand wash, dry thoroughly
5. Misen Carbon Nonstick Frying Pan, 12 Inch
The Misen takes a different construction route. The listing describes a nitrided carbon steel pan with an aluminum core, which pairs the heat responsiveness of an aluminum layer with a carbon steel cooking surface. Nitriding is a treatment of the steel itself rather than an applied coating, and the maker presents the surface as naturally nonstick with no coating to chip or peel. That also means there is no traditional seasoning routine to manage.
At 12 inches with a listed capacity of 3 quarts, this is one of the two largest options in the group. The product information lists a maximum temperature of 500 degrees Fahrenheit, and the pan is listed as compatible with induction, gas, and electric stovetops and safe for oven use. If you like the idea of carbon steel but not the seasoning learning curve, this is the design aimed at you; cooks who want a traditional bare steel pan should look at the French options above instead.
Specs
- Diameter: 12 inches
- Material: nitrided carbon steel with an aluminum core, per the listing
- Capacity: 3 quarts
- Maximum temperature: 500 degrees Fahrenheit, per the product information
- Surface: nitrided, with no applied coating, per the maker
- Compatibility: induction, gas, and electric stovetops; oven safe
- Seasoning routine: none described by the maker
How to Choose
Start with size. An 8.5 to 10 inch pan handles eggs, single portions, and small sides, while a 12 inch pan is the better default for family portions and searing several pieces of protein at once. Remember that the flat cooking surface is always smaller than the rim diameter, especially on sloped French-style pans, so compare cooking surface measurements where listings provide them.
Next, decide how much break-in you accept. Bare French pans from de Buyer and Matfer arrive unseasoned or with a protective coating to remove, and they reward the effort with a surface that is entirely your own seasoning. Pre-seasoned pans from Lodge and Merten and Storck shorten that process, and the nitrided Misen removes it, at the cost of a less traditional construction.
Finally, check the details that affect daily use: whether the handle is riveted or welded, whether the pan is induction compatible, the stated oven temperature limit, and the weight. A heavier pan holds heat steadier for searing, while a lighter one is easier to toss and lift.
Who Should Skip
Skip carbon steel entirely if you want cookware that goes in the dishwasher or soaks in the sink, because standing water and harsh detergents strip seasoning and invite rust. Also skip it if you cook a lot of long-simmered acidic dishes such as tomato sauces, since acids wear the seasoning layer; an enameled or stainless pan suits that cooking better.
Skip the unseasoned French pans if you do not want any break-in period, and skip the Misen if a traditional single-material pan matters to you, since its aluminum core and nitrided surface are a modern variation rather than the classic construction.
FAQ
Does a carbon steel pan need to be seasoned before first use?
It depends on the pan. Bare carbon steel, like the de Buyer and Matfer picks here, needs its protective coating removed and a seasoning layer applied before cooking. Pre-seasoned pans from Lodge and Merten and Storck can be cooked with right away after a wash, and the nitrided Misen describes no seasoning routine at all.
Can carbon steel pans be used on induction cooktops?
Yes, as long as the base is flat and the listing states induction compatibility. The Matfer, Merten and Storck, and Misen listings all state induction compatibility, and carbon steel is a magnetic material. Check the listing for the specific size you are ordering, since compatibility notes can vary by model.
How do you clean a carbon steel pan without ruining the seasoning?
Wash it by hand with hot water and a brush or non-metal scrubber, using mild soap only if the maker allows it, then dry it completely, ideally on a warm burner. A thin wipe of oil before storage helps protect the surface. Avoid soaking and dishwashers, which strip seasoning and can cause rust.
Why did food stick in my new carbon steel pan?
Early sticking is normal while the seasoning layer is still thin. Preheat the pan before adding oil and food, give proteins time to release on their own instead of forcing them, and keep cooking with fats. The surface improves steadily over the first weeks of use.
Final Verdict
Carbon steel rewards cooks who keep a simple care routine. Choose the de Buyer MINERAL B for a roomy, traditional French skillet, the Matfer 8.5 inch for a compact welded-handle pan, the Merten and Storck for a large pre-seasoned all-rounder, the Lodge bundle for a made-in-USA starter with handle holders included, or the Misen for a no-seasoning nitrided design. Match the size to your household, and any of the five can be a long-term pan.
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.
Explore Subscribe & SaveCollect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.
Create a wedding registryFree shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!