Updated Nov 21, 2026· 9 min read

Key takeaways

  • Compare the best pie dishes in glass, stoneware, ceramic and steel, with sizes, depths, oven limits and honest notes on browning and thermal shock.

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Our top pick: Pyrex Bakeware 9.5-Inch Scalloped Glass Pie Plate (2-Pack). Runner-up: OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid.

A pie dish looks simple, but its material quietly decides how your pie turns out. Glass heats slowly and lets you watch the bottom crust change colour. Metal grabs heat fast and browns the base before the filling overcooks. Stoneware and ceramic hold heat long after the oven is off, keeping a served pie warm. Depth matters too: a deep-dish apple pie will bubble over in a standard plate.

This guide compares five widely sold pie dishes across glass, stoneware, ceramic and aluminized steel, listing each maker’s stated size, depth, oven limit and broiler guidance. One honesty note: no glass dish is immune to thermal shock, and every maker below publishes limits for a reason.

How to Choose a Pie Dish

Start with diameter and depth. Nine inches is the standard most recipes assume. A 9.5-inch plate spreads the same filling thinner, so expect a shallower slice and roll the crust wider. Depth is the bigger variable. Standard plates run about 1 to 1.5 inches deep and suit single-crust pies. Deep-dish models around 2 inches deep hold double-crust fruit pies without spillover, but the extra filling adds bake time — often 10 to 20 minutes more.

Match the material to the crust you want. Metal conducts heat fastest, browning and crisping bottom crusts quickest — a gift for wet fruit fillings, a risk for delicate custards. Glass is a slow, gentle conductor that holds heat steadily, and its transparency lets you check the base without lifting the pie. Stoneware and ceramic sit in between: slower than metal, excellent at holding warmth, and pretty enough for the table.

Respect thermal shock limits. Glass can shatter when a hot dish meets a cold or wet surface, or when a fridge-cold dish enters a ripping-hot oven. Makers of US glass bakeware say: preheated oven only, never a broiler or stovetop, and set hot glass on a dry cloth or trivet. Borosilicate tolerates temperature swings better than soda-lime glass, and one ceramic maker below rates its dish for freezer-to-hot-oven use — but that rating applies to that maker’s clay and process, not to ceramic in general.

Check the rim and the extras. Fluted or scalloped rims help you crimp a decorative edge. Wide flat rims are easier to carry with oven mitts. A fitted lid — offered by only one pick here — adds storage and transport.

1. Pyrex Bakeware 9.5-Inch Scalloped Glass Pie Plate (2-Pack)

The Pyrex scalloped plate is the dish many bakers learn on: clear glass, a wavy fluted rim that makes crimping almost automatic, and a two-pack format for baking one pie to serve and one to give away. The transparent base lets you pull the pie when the bottom is genuinely golden. US-made Pyrex is tempered soda-lime glass, so treat it gently: preheated oven only, no sudden temperature swings.

Specs

  • Diameter and depth: 9.5 in diameter; standard shallow profile (no exact depth published)
  • Material: tempered glass (US soda-lime formula), non-porous, resists odours and stains
  • Oven limit: preheated oven only; the maker publishes no single maximum temperature
  • Broiler safe: no — also not for stovetop, grill or toaster oven use
  • Rim: scalloped/fluted edge for easy crimping; no handles
  • Freezer-to-oven: freezer, microwave and dishwasher safe; the maker warns against abrupt temperature changes rather than promising freezer-to-hot-oven use

Pros:
– Clear base lets you check bottom-crust colour directly
– Scalloped rim guides neat, even crimps
– Two plates for batch or gift baking
– Dishwasher, microwave and freezer safe per the maker

Cons:
– Soda-lime glass is the most thermal-shock-sensitive material here
– No lid and no handles, so transport is awkward
– 9.5 in size spreads standard 9 in fillings slightly thin

Who it suits: Traditionalists who bake classic single-crust pies, want to see the crust bake, and will follow glass-handling rules carefully.

2. OXO Good Grips Glass Pie Plate with Lid

OXO’s plate solves the two annoyances of glass pie dishes: fragility and leftovers. The glass is borosilicate, formulated to handle wider temperature swings than soda-lime glass, and OXO rates it for freezer-to-oven use within its stated limit. The snap-on lid is for storage and transport only — never the oven — but a finished pie travels from counter to fridge to a friend’s house in the same dish.

Specs

  • Diameter and depth: 9 in diameter; deep-profile plate, 1.4 qt capacity
  • Material: borosilicate glass
  • Oven limit: 450°F in a preheated oven, as stated by the maker
  • Broiler safe: no
  • Rim and lid: smooth rim; BPA-free plastic lid included for storage (not oven safe)
  • Freezer-to-oven: yes, per the maker — also rated for microwave and dishwasher use

Pros:
– Borosilicate glass handles temperature changes better than standard glass
– Included lid makes storage and potluck transport simple
– Standard 9 in size matches most recipes exactly
– Clear glass still lets you monitor the bottom crust

Cons:
– Lid is plastic and must stay out of the oven
– Not broiler safe, so no last-minute top browning under high heat
– Deeper profile can add a few minutes for single-crust pies

Who it suits: Bakers who carry pies to gatherings or store leftovers in the baking dish, and anyone who wants glass with a wider safety margin.

3. Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Pie Dish, 9-Inch

Le Creuset’s Heritage dish is the oven-to-table option: dense stoneware with a coloured glaze, a fluted edge, and angled side walls that help slices lift out neatly. Stoneware heats evenly and holds warmth through second helpings. It is the heaviest style here, and the glaze — though scratch-resistant — still deserves wooden or silicone servers rather than a metal knife.

Specs

  • Diameter and depth: 9 in diameter (about 10.2 in across the rim); standard depth
  • Material: glazed stoneware
  • Oven limit: 500°F upper temperature rating, as listed
  • Broiler safe: not listed for broiler use — the maker lists oven, microwave and freezer use
  • Rim: fluted/scalloped edge with angled side walls for clean serving
  • Freezer-to-oven: freezer safe per the maker; avoid extreme sudden temperature jumps

Pros:
– Even heat distribution with no hot spots, per the maker
– Glazed finish goes straight from oven to table
– Dense stoneware keeps served pie warm longer
– Dishwasher, microwave and freezer safe

Cons:
– Heavier than glass or metal, especially when full
– You cannot see the bottom crust while it bakes
– Not rated for broiler finishing

Who it suits: Bakers who serve pie in its baking dish — holidays, pot pies, quiches — and value presentation and heat retention over crust visibility.

4. Emile Henry Modern Classics 9-Inch Pie Dish

Emile Henry fires its dishes from Burgundy clay into what it calls HR (high resistance) ceramic, and makes the boldest temperature claim here: the dish is rated to go directly from freezer to hot oven. That suits make-ahead bakers who freeze a raw pie and bake it later without thawing. The Modern Classics shape is a deep dish with smooth, tall sides, handling fruit fillings, quiches and pot pies that would swamp a standard plate.

Specs

  • Diameter and depth: 9 in diameter; deep-dish profile, 1.4 qt capacity
  • Material: HR ceramic from high-fired Burgundy clay, glazed
  • Oven limit: 520°F, as stated by the maker for its HR ceramic
  • Broiler safe: not stated by the maker; oven, microwave, freezer and dishwasher are the listed uses
  • Rim: smooth rolled rim; no handles, no fluting
  • Freezer-to-oven: yes — the maker explicitly rates it for freezer-to-hot-oven use

Pros:
– Only pick here rated to go straight from freezer to hot oven
– Deep profile suits double-crust and high fruit fillings
– Ceramic retains heat well for serving
– Maker backs it with a 10-year guarantee against manufacturing defects

Cons:
– Smooth rim offers no crimping guide, unlike fluted dishes
– Ceramic hides the bottom crust while baking
– Deep fillings need longer than the same pie in a shallow plate

Who it suits: Make-ahead and freezer bakers, and deep-dish devotees who want one ceramic dish for pies, quiches and pot pies.

5. USA Pan Bakeware Aluminized Steel Pie Pan, 9-Inch

USA Pan’s pie pan is the metal representative: heavy-gauge aluminized steel with a corrugated surface and the company’s Americoat silicone nonstick coating. Metal is the fastest heat conductor here, so this pan crisps and browns a bottom crust most aggressively — a real advantage with juicy fillings that threaten soggy bases in glass. The corrugation resists warping, and a steel wire in the rim keeps the pan flat at temperature.

Specs

  • Diameter and depth: 9 in diameter x 1.5 in deep (baking surface)
  • Material: aluminized steel with Americoat silicone nonstick coating (PTFE-, PFOA- and BPA-free, per the maker)
  • Oven limit: 450°F upper temperature rating
  • Broiler safe: no — the coating sets the 450°F ceiling
  • Rim: flat, reinforced with a steel wire to resist warping; no handles
  • Freezer-to-oven: freezer safe per the maker; hand washing recommended to protect the coating

Pros:
– Fastest, deepest bottom-crust browning of the five
– Nonstick surface releases slices cleanly
– Corrugated, wire-rimmed build resists warping
– Lightweight and unbreakable compared with glass or ceramic

Cons:
– Opaque — no way to check the crust colour mid-bake
– Hand washing recommended; the coating will not last forever
– Fast browning can over-darken delicate custard edges

Who it suits: Fruit-pie bakers fighting soggy bottoms, and anyone who wants a light, durable everyday pan and can judge doneness by time and top colour.

Comparison Table

Dish Material Size Depth Oven Limit Broiler Freezer-to-Oven Extras
Pyrex Scalloped Pie Plate (2-Pack) Tempered glass 9.5 in Standard (exact depth not published) Preheated oven; no max published No Freezer safe; avoid sudden changes Fluted rim
OXO Good Grips Pie Plate with Lid Borosilicate glass 9 in Deep profile, 1.4 qt 450°F No Yes, per maker Storage lid included
Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish Stoneware 9 in Standard 500°F Not listed Freezer safe Fluted rim, glazed colours
Emile Henry Modern Classics Pie Dish HR ceramic 9 in Deep dish, 1.4 qt 520°F Not stated Yes, explicitly rated 10-year maker guarantee
USA Pan Pie Pan Aluminized steel 9 in 1.5 in 450°F No Freezer safe Nonstick coating, corrugated surface

Frequently Asked Questions

Which material gives the crispiest bottom crust?
Metal, because it conducts heat into the base fastest. Glass and ceramic brown more gently; a metal pan like the USA Pan is the straightforward fix for chronically pale, soggy bottoms. Placing any dish on a preheated baking sheet also helps.

Can I put a frozen pie straight into the oven in a glass dish?
Only if the maker rates that dish for it. Standard glass plates carry warnings against abrupt temperature changes, and thermal shock can shatter them. Borosilicate glass (the OXO) and the Emile Henry ceramic are rated for freezer-to-oven use within their limits; the Pyrex soda-lime plate is not.

Is a deep-dish pie dish better than a standard one?
Neither is better outright — they bake differently. Deep dishes hold more filling, which needs a longer bake and sets more slowly in the centre. Standard plates suit custard, pumpkin and pecan pies. If you bake everything, one of each covers most recipes.

Why did my glass pie plate crack in the oven?
Usually thermal shock: a cold dish entering a very hot oven, hot glass set on a wet or cold counter, or liquid added to a hot dry dish. Makers advise a preheated oven, no broiler or stovetop, and resting hot glass on a dry cloth or wooden board.

Do I need to adjust a recipe written for a 9-inch plate if my dish is 9.5 inches?
Slightly. The filling spreads thinner, so the pie may bake a few minutes faster and slice shallower. Roll the crust larger to keep overhang for crimping.

Conclusion

For most bakers, the OXO borosilicate plate is the balanced choice: standard size, a forgiving glass formula, and a lid for effortless storage. If seeing the crust is your priority, the Pyrex two-pack remains a classic — just respect its temperature rules. Choose the Le Creuset for serving from a beautiful dish, the Emile Henry if you freeze pies before baking, and the USA Pan when a crisp, well-browned bottom crust matters most.

H
Healthy Kitchen Plus Editorial Team
We compare specs, materials and verified owner reviews before a product earns a spot. Rankings are never paid.
Affiliate disclosure. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Prices accurate as of the date shown.
Best Pie Dishes: 5 Top Picks for Flaky,…Check price on Amazon

More from Amazon

Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.

Subscribe & Save

Set up recurring deliveries of everyday items on eligible products. Terms and savings are set by Amazon.

Explore Subscribe & Save
Amazon Wedding Registry

Collect the home and kitchen items you want in one registry that guests can shop from.

Create a wedding registry
Amazon Prime

Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Start a Prime free trial
Audible

Audiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.

Try Audible free

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.